When Life Doesn't Go According to Plan
There's a haunting experiment from the 1950s that reveals something profound about the human condition. A physiologist named Curt Richter placed rats in containers of water to observe how long they would swim before giving up. The results were startling: wild rats, stronger and more aggressive, lasted only about 15 minutes. Domesticated rats, however, kept swimming for hours.
The difference wasn't physical strength. It was hope.
When Richter modified the experiment, rescuing the wild rats just before drowning and then placing them back in the water, something remarkable happened. These rats, now conditioned to believe rescue was possible, didn't just swim a little longer. They swam for 60 hours—240 times longer than before.
Their bodies hadn't changed. The struggle was identical. But their belief had transformed everything.
Treading Water in Real Life
Most of us know what it feels like to tread water—not physically, but emotionally, mentally, spiritually. We keep showing up, carrying responsibilities, doing what needs to be done, all while wondering how much longer we can keep it up.
Life doesn't always fall apart all at once. Sometimes it's subtler. It's the slow build of disappointment, the prayer that seems to go unanswered, the pressure that keeps mounting. We're doing everything we know to do, yet something still feels heavy.
Hopelessness doesn't arrive with fanfare. It settles in quietly, lowering our expectations. We don't stop believing in God altogether, but we stop expecting much from Him. We keep going through the motions, but inwardly, the questions rise: Is this all life is going to be? Is this really what it means to follow God—to just keep barely staying afloat?
When Everything Goes Wrong
The early church in Acts 6 was experiencing unprecedented momentum. The word of God was spreading rapidly. Disciples were multiplying daily. Even priests—those firmly rooted in Jewish religious society—were turning their lives toward Jesus.
Stephen, described as "a man full of God's grace and power," was doing great wonders and miraculous signs among the people. Everything was going right.
Then everything went wrong.
Opposition arose. When Stephen's accusers couldn't refute his arguments, they resorted to lies, secretly persuading men to claim they'd heard Stephen speak blasphemy. He was dragged before the religious court, where witness after witness stood up with false testimony.
Instead of merely defending himself, Stephen launched into a powerful journey through Jewish history, proving that Jesus was the fulfillment of God's promise. He didn't stop with explanation—he called out the religious leaders for condemning Jesus to death.
If you knew the story of the early church up to this point, you'd expect something amazing to happen next. Peter's sermon in Acts 2 led to 3,000 conversions. When Peter and John stood trial after healing a crippled beggar, the religious leaders were astonished and couldn't punish them because everyone was praising God.
Surely Stephen's powerful sermon would produce a similar breakthrough. Maybe this would be the moment the religious elite finally understood what they'd been missing.
But that's not what happened.
Instead, they were furious. They covered their ears, rushed at Stephen, dragged him outside the city, and stoned him to death. That day, a great persecution broke out against the church, and believers were scattered throughout Judea and Samaria.
It wasn't supposed to go like this.
God's Plan Doesn't Always Look Like Ours
We all want to be in God's will. We pray for it, seek it, long for it. But what does that actually mean?
When we think "plan," we think order, pattern, predictability. We expect logical progression: first this happens, which sets up that, then this. A good plan shouldn't leave us uncertain about what comes next.
Yet God's plan often looks like the opposite. It looks like chaos.
Because His plan rarely resembles ours, it's easy to assume things are falling apart long before He's done. We look at our circumstances through a narrow viewpoint: This looks like a bad situation, so it must produce a negative result. This doesn't look like part of a plan, so it must not be part of God's plan.
But what if the unanticipated, the unexpected, the dead end could be part of something good that God is doing in your life—you just can't see it because it's currently wrapped in disappointment?
Don't close the chapter on a story God isn't finished writing.
The Paradox of Persecution
At first glance, Stephen's death and the persecution of the church were purely awful. Death and persecution never belong in the "good" category of life.
Yet some scholars call this one of the greatest events in history. Why?
Because the persecution actually forced the early church to follow through with what Jesus had called them to do. Jesus's last instructions were clear: wait in Jerusalem for the Holy Spirit, then take the power received and go to the ends of the earth as witnesses.
They got the "wait in Jerusalem" part down. But they didn't actually go anywhere beyond Jerusalem until they were forced to leave.
Acts 8:4 tells us: "Those who had been scattered preached the word wherever they went."
Persecution threatened their safety, but it also spread the gospel in a way that might not have happened otherwise.
Was this bad or good? The answer is yes. Yes, persecution was terrible. But simultaneously, yes, what came as a result was good.
The Apostle Paul captured this complexity perfectly when he wrote from prison: "Now I want you to know, brothers, that what has happened to me has really served to advance the gospel" (Philippians 1:12).
Redefining Expectations
So what do we do with our own moments when life doesn't go according to plan?
We adjust our expectations—not by lowering them, but by redefining them. This isn't about expecting the worst to avoid disappointment. It's about developing such confidence in God's faithfulness that we start looking for the good even when all we see is bad.
Paul wrote, "All things work together for the good of those who love God" (Romans 8:28). The power of that verse isn't some far-off hope that maybe it'll work out someday. The power is that you can adjust your expectations in the middle of what you're going through.
You can actually start asking: How can this turn out for my good? What good could emerge from this? How can God use this part of my story to bring Him glory?
There isn't always an obvious answer. But asking the question reframes our perspective. Instead of looking at what was supposed to be good and only seeing the bad, we look at something bad and start to believe for something more.
The Gift of Discomfort
Consider the lobster—a soft animal living inside a rigid shell. That shell protects against predators, but it also prevents growth. As the lobster gets bigger, the shell that once provided safety becomes a prison. It gets uncomfortable, confined.
To grow, the lobster must become vulnerable. It must shed its shell to grow a new one. A lobster does this repeatedly throughout its life.
The motivation for growth is discomfort. Without discomfort, the lobster would never make itself vulnerable enough to shed its old life.
What if we viewed the pressures of life through this perspective? What if the comfort we've been holding onto has become our prison? What if the challenge we're facing isn't going to destroy us but is an opportunity to grow toward the purpose God designed us for?
Swimming Toward Hope
Like those rats in Richter's experiment, we have a choice. We can give in to hopelessness, or we can remember that rescue is possible. We can tread water waiting for the end, or we can keep swimming with the confidence that God is not done yet.
Your struggle may be real. The water may be deep. But God wants to use what you're going through. The pressure you're facing might be the very thing that propels you into your next season of growth.
Keep swimming. The story isn't over.
The difference wasn't physical strength. It was hope.
When Richter modified the experiment, rescuing the wild rats just before drowning and then placing them back in the water, something remarkable happened. These rats, now conditioned to believe rescue was possible, didn't just swim a little longer. They swam for 60 hours—240 times longer than before.
Their bodies hadn't changed. The struggle was identical. But their belief had transformed everything.
Treading Water in Real Life
Most of us know what it feels like to tread water—not physically, but emotionally, mentally, spiritually. We keep showing up, carrying responsibilities, doing what needs to be done, all while wondering how much longer we can keep it up.
Life doesn't always fall apart all at once. Sometimes it's subtler. It's the slow build of disappointment, the prayer that seems to go unanswered, the pressure that keeps mounting. We're doing everything we know to do, yet something still feels heavy.
Hopelessness doesn't arrive with fanfare. It settles in quietly, lowering our expectations. We don't stop believing in God altogether, but we stop expecting much from Him. We keep going through the motions, but inwardly, the questions rise: Is this all life is going to be? Is this really what it means to follow God—to just keep barely staying afloat?
When Everything Goes Wrong
The early church in Acts 6 was experiencing unprecedented momentum. The word of God was spreading rapidly. Disciples were multiplying daily. Even priests—those firmly rooted in Jewish religious society—were turning their lives toward Jesus.
Stephen, described as "a man full of God's grace and power," was doing great wonders and miraculous signs among the people. Everything was going right.
Then everything went wrong.
Opposition arose. When Stephen's accusers couldn't refute his arguments, they resorted to lies, secretly persuading men to claim they'd heard Stephen speak blasphemy. He was dragged before the religious court, where witness after witness stood up with false testimony.
Instead of merely defending himself, Stephen launched into a powerful journey through Jewish history, proving that Jesus was the fulfillment of God's promise. He didn't stop with explanation—he called out the religious leaders for condemning Jesus to death.
If you knew the story of the early church up to this point, you'd expect something amazing to happen next. Peter's sermon in Acts 2 led to 3,000 conversions. When Peter and John stood trial after healing a crippled beggar, the religious leaders were astonished and couldn't punish them because everyone was praising God.
Surely Stephen's powerful sermon would produce a similar breakthrough. Maybe this would be the moment the religious elite finally understood what they'd been missing.
But that's not what happened.
Instead, they were furious. They covered their ears, rushed at Stephen, dragged him outside the city, and stoned him to death. That day, a great persecution broke out against the church, and believers were scattered throughout Judea and Samaria.
It wasn't supposed to go like this.
God's Plan Doesn't Always Look Like Ours
We all want to be in God's will. We pray for it, seek it, long for it. But what does that actually mean?
When we think "plan," we think order, pattern, predictability. We expect logical progression: first this happens, which sets up that, then this. A good plan shouldn't leave us uncertain about what comes next.
Yet God's plan often looks like the opposite. It looks like chaos.
Because His plan rarely resembles ours, it's easy to assume things are falling apart long before He's done. We look at our circumstances through a narrow viewpoint: This looks like a bad situation, so it must produce a negative result. This doesn't look like part of a plan, so it must not be part of God's plan.
But what if the unanticipated, the unexpected, the dead end could be part of something good that God is doing in your life—you just can't see it because it's currently wrapped in disappointment?
Don't close the chapter on a story God isn't finished writing.
The Paradox of Persecution
At first glance, Stephen's death and the persecution of the church were purely awful. Death and persecution never belong in the "good" category of life.
Yet some scholars call this one of the greatest events in history. Why?
Because the persecution actually forced the early church to follow through with what Jesus had called them to do. Jesus's last instructions were clear: wait in Jerusalem for the Holy Spirit, then take the power received and go to the ends of the earth as witnesses.
They got the "wait in Jerusalem" part down. But they didn't actually go anywhere beyond Jerusalem until they were forced to leave.
Acts 8:4 tells us: "Those who had been scattered preached the word wherever they went."
Persecution threatened their safety, but it also spread the gospel in a way that might not have happened otherwise.
Was this bad or good? The answer is yes. Yes, persecution was terrible. But simultaneously, yes, what came as a result was good.
The Apostle Paul captured this complexity perfectly when he wrote from prison: "Now I want you to know, brothers, that what has happened to me has really served to advance the gospel" (Philippians 1:12).
Redefining Expectations
So what do we do with our own moments when life doesn't go according to plan?
We adjust our expectations—not by lowering them, but by redefining them. This isn't about expecting the worst to avoid disappointment. It's about developing such confidence in God's faithfulness that we start looking for the good even when all we see is bad.
Paul wrote, "All things work together for the good of those who love God" (Romans 8:28). The power of that verse isn't some far-off hope that maybe it'll work out someday. The power is that you can adjust your expectations in the middle of what you're going through.
You can actually start asking: How can this turn out for my good? What good could emerge from this? How can God use this part of my story to bring Him glory?
There isn't always an obvious answer. But asking the question reframes our perspective. Instead of looking at what was supposed to be good and only seeing the bad, we look at something bad and start to believe for something more.
The Gift of Discomfort
Consider the lobster—a soft animal living inside a rigid shell. That shell protects against predators, but it also prevents growth. As the lobster gets bigger, the shell that once provided safety becomes a prison. It gets uncomfortable, confined.
To grow, the lobster must become vulnerable. It must shed its shell to grow a new one. A lobster does this repeatedly throughout its life.
The motivation for growth is discomfort. Without discomfort, the lobster would never make itself vulnerable enough to shed its old life.
What if we viewed the pressures of life through this perspective? What if the comfort we've been holding onto has become our prison? What if the challenge we're facing isn't going to destroy us but is an opportunity to grow toward the purpose God designed us for?
Swimming Toward Hope
Like those rats in Richter's experiment, we have a choice. We can give in to hopelessness, or we can remember that rescue is possible. We can tread water waiting for the end, or we can keep swimming with the confidence that God is not done yet.
Your struggle may be real. The water may be deep. But God wants to use what you're going through. The pressure you're facing might be the very thing that propels you into your next season of growth.
Keep swimming. The story isn't over.
Recent
Archive
2026
January
February
March
April
2025
January
February
March
May
June
July
August
September
October
November
Categories
no categories
No Comments